Plump up the Volume: Interview with Princess Lili Kathleen Hardy

Mrs. Cooper (aka Shelly Johnson):  “Scarlett” doesn’t suit you dear.

Becky (aka Lili Reinhardt):  Well, I like it.  It makes me feel powerful.–Riverdale

Jessica: What color lipstick are you wearing?

Helen: Well it’s three different kinds. I blend. I start with MAC Viva Glam 3.

Jessica: Uh-huh.

Helen: Which is a great base, and then I add Prescriptives Poodle on top.

Jessica: Oh my God I love Prescriptives, it’s the best.

Helen: I know, isn’t it?

Jessica: The moisture and the . . . It’s great.

Helen:  Then I finish with Philosophy Super Natural Nude, which is more of a . . .

Jessica: Of a glossy, kinda?

Helen: Exactly, a little bit of shine.—Kissing Jessica Stein

Lili Kathleen Hardy is cute and a beaut who walks with aplomb and spunk to spare.  What’s not to love about this Miss Ooh La, Montana girl, who once marched midway into a Taco Tuesday party with a loaf of ready-made garlic bread under her arm.

“This is just for me,” as she deftly heats the oven to 350 degrees.

Lil Lil’s tagline: “Garlic, I’m interested.”

Write Between the Lines is interested in Lil Lil’s beauty routine.

Through the looking glass, she graciously takes time to teach good face.  Apply the maquillage to the visage.

Lili:  So, what I do first thing, if I know I’m going to put my makeup on within the next hour, is moisturize.  Prep my face so it’s hydrated and sticky.  I won’t moisturize after I wash my face, if I have more time.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: What’s the rationale?

Lili:  Moisturizing serum.  I always start with my eyebrows, always

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: Side note:  We both go to Chandler Husband at the Beauty Strip for waxing.

Lili:  Omg, luv Chandler.  Shape the brows with concealer.  Eyebrow pencil and a pomade.  If I don’t really care, I’ll just use a pencil.  I’ll always start back to front: fill in the eyebrow up to the front fourth.  Blend it out with the spoolly brush using super simple hair strokes.  Blend it out again so it’s not so harsh.  More natural, not so blocky.

Then, I will set them with clear brow gel I like twice instead of once, so I know they’ll stay if I go out all day.  Next, I’ll shape the brow with Anastasia “soft glam” palette, Jouer Cosmetics Essential High Coverage Liquid Concealer, so I know the shape they’ll take.  I always start on the top part of below my brow.  After the bottom I’ll do the top, same thing: create shape that stands out in sharp relief to the skin.  If I make it too thin on accident, or I don’t shape it well enough, I’ll go back in with a brush.

Lili checks her look in the mirror and kicks up her heel.

Lili: Next eyes.  I like to prime with concealer, then blend it out.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: Why not foundation first?

Lili: Tons of fallout and it messes up your face.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: How do you choose your color?

Lili: I just look at the palette.  I set my eyelids with translucent powder so it doesn’t crease.  Tap, not swipe.  Hmmm. Transition shade.  Matte or shimmery?

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: Matte.

Lili:  Burnt orange.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: Is that the same palette I use?

Lili:  It’s Anastasia’s Soft Glam Eyeshadow Palette.  You have Modern Renaissance.  I do beat it into a pulp, using this Morphe M167.  Blend with a big fluffy brush.  Build up the transition color.  Darker, Darker, Darker.  Don’t go too fast.  The transition color can be lighter or darker; neutral blends everything together.  Deepen the crease brush fluffy more tapered Lexi 249.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: When did you start playing with makeup?

Lili:  Twelve?  I started doing it in 7th grade.  I got serious when I was fifteen.   I didn’t get good at it until I was sixteen, seventeen.  That’s when I could actually pull off full glam looks and not feel stupid.

Lili’s hip shifts to one side, her feet Battement tendu into second position.

Lili:  Once I’m done with the eyelids: eyeliner.

Lili locates the Kat Von D Tattoo Liner.

Lili:  Yep, it’s a banger.  My holy grail.

Wing flipping back and forth swoop with precision light brush strokes.  Stops to admire the thick wing line that frames the matte shadow.

Peaches and cream complexion.  Button nose, nary a blink.

Lili:  Then I’ll check if the length to see if one is thicker or longer than the other.  If so, I’ll make adjustments.  False eyelashes:  Black lash glue if I have liner, clear glue if I don’t.  Glue on first until it’s tacky then I’ll put on mascara.  I won’t curl them at all.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: Which mascara do you use?

Lili:  It literally changes every day.  I pick at random.  Loreal Telescopic Volumizer is a really good drugstore mascara dup for Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara.

“I do my hair toss, check my nails
Baby, how you feelin’? (Feelin’ good as hell.)” Lizzo

Prep and prime.

Lili:  Eye cream if I just washed my face.  Put on the moisturizer with little dabs.  While this setting in the skin, I get out my beloved beauty blender.  I change it every three months.  Always get your bb damp so it expands.  I wring it out with a towel, and let it sit while I prime my face using a lil Bye Bye Pores primer t-zone.  Also, sometimes if you take too much pore filler, it balls up in your hand that’s how you know.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: Where do you buy your products?

Lili:  Sephora and Ulta.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻: Nigel’s gives us the NoHo neighborhood discount.

Lili:  Foundation literally depends on what is the right shade of face.  At home I use a tray.  While traveling, I put it on my hand, then dot it all over my face.  Polka dots. I like to use a brush to blend it.  It’s just not attractive to see a line between foundation and the real face.  Concealer under eyes, dab with beauty blender.

Big fluffy brush with translucent powder.

Contour.

🆆[🅱🆃]🅻:  Blush changes every day. 

She plumps up a half smile for the apple of the cheek, and brushes the blush swiftly away towards the hairline.

Lili:  Melt everything into your face so it’s not so cakey.  Fan everything with the highlight’s brush.  Put some on my nose and cupid’s bow.  If it’s too intense, blend it out a little.

Highlight brow bone matte on my eyes’ inner corner is my fave thing to do.  Eyeliner outer corner of my lash line blend out with brush.  Urban Decay setting spray 30 sprays drench my face doesn’t move for the rest of the day.

Touch ups.  Brush teeth.  Do lips.  Outline with Kylie Cosmetic Candy K.  It is my basically my lip color, but better.  Fenty lip gloss, and that’s it.

Write Between the Lines takeaway?  Blend always.  Lili blending in? Hard(l)y.

@makeupby.lili

Gel Polish

by LB Nye

Claudia said she couldn’t take me, but here she was moving other people around so she could take me right away.  A manicure emergency.

An emergency ‘cause the funeral is in a couple of hours and I’m not gonna bury my mother with chipped nails.  Gel polish ‘cause death gets the good nails. 

Claudia tore in with the cuticle clippers and the files. Nobody ever said Claudia was gentle.  Nails come out good, though.  She says, “Don’t flinch, I got sharp implements here.”  I say, “You’re gonna draw blood.”

Acetone smells like my first manicure, hanging with Mom and my aunts.  Makes you feel like a grown up, walking around with those perfect nails.  Base coat and top coat.  Perfect, Claudia got the skills.  Then the color.  Red, red, red, the color of Chianti.  And rub ‘em down.  Mom likes the pale colors, pinks and such.  But she doesn’t have an opinion, anymore. 

So, the thing you do is, after Claudia is all done, is you set your fingers under UV light, a minute, maybe two.  Two if you want it to really last.  There’s some chemistry in there, free radicals set off by the UV wavelengths, bonding up, hard as crystal.  So, I sit still; the radicals get to be free.    

I tip Claudia good and she taps the back of my hand, “hang in there.”

Nicest she’s ever been to me.

American Beauty

by KEM Huntley

“Welcome to America’s Weirdest Home Videos”—an apt line from American Beauty, director Sam Mendes and screenwriter Alan Ball’s stark art set piece of individual torment and family calamity. Familiar familial territory immediately reminiscent of Ordinary People and The Ice Storm (films that influenced Mendes, Premiere 10/99), American Beauty is a Dramatica grand argument story that compels us to “look closer” at pain and mundane, and life will reveal the spectacular.

INANITY

Main character Lester Burnham recounts in voice-over: “I’m forty-two-years old. In less than a year, I’ll be dead. In a way, I’m dead already. . . Both my wife and daughter think I’m this gigantic loser (overall story problem-perception). And they’re right (main character problem-perception). I’ve lost something very important. I’m not exactly sure what it is, but I know I didn’t always feel this . . . sedated (main character focus-inertia). But you know what? It’s never too late to get it back” (main character growth-start).

At Lester’s ad agency, it has been decided (overall story driver) that: “. . . everyone write a job description, mapping out in detail how they contribute. That way, management can assess who’s valuable and who’s ‘expendable'” (overall story concern conceptualizing). Lester objects (main character approach-do-er) to this “fascist” order (overall story focus), Wife Carolyn, a study in glacial ambition, asserts: “There is no decision. Just write the damn thing! . . . you don’t want to be unemployed” (overall story direction-chaos).

Lester sulkily attends daughter Jane’s high school dance performance with Carolyn: “What makes you so sure she wants us to be there? Did she ask us to come? . . . I’m missing the James Bond marathon on TNT.”

Jane’s best friend and fellow “Dancing Pantherette” Angela Hayes (allusion to Nabokov’s Lolita Haze?) catapults Lester out of his malaise: “I feel like I’ve been in a coma for about twenty years (main character concern-past), and I’m just now waking up” (main character growth-start), priming him for impact character Ricky Fitts.

Apathetically escorting Carolyn to a realtor’s function: “Lester, listen to me. This is important . . . as you know, my business is selling an image (overall story problem-perception) . . . do me a favor and act happy” (overall story benchmark-being).  Lester is approached by Ricky, a waiter in the hotel:

RICKY
I’m Ricky Fitts. I just moved into the house next to you . . . Hey, do you party? (relationship story concern-doing).

LESTER
I’m sorry?

RICKY
Do you get high?

Lester’s surprised, but instantly intrigued . . .  Ricky and Lester stand next to a dumpster behind the service entrance to the hotel, smoking a JOINT (relationship story thematic issue-senses) . . .  Suddenly . . . a serious young MAN in a cheap suit peers out at them. Ricky hides the joint.

MAN
(to Ricky)

Look. I’m not paying you to . . . (eyes Lester suspiciously) . . . do whatever it is you’re doing out here (relationship story catalyst-interpretation).

RICKY
Fine. Don’t pay me . . .  I quit (impact character driver-change). Now, leave me alone.

LESTER
I think you just became my personal hero (relationship story concern-understanding). Doesn’t that make you nervous, just quitting your job like that?

RICKY
. . . I just do these gigs every now and then as a cover. . .  But my dad (impact character domain-mind) interferes a lot less in my life when I pretend (overall story benchmark-being) to be an upstanding young citizen with a respectable job (overall story problem-perception).

Like all the objective characters in American Beauty, Ricky has his own agenda (overall story domain-psychology). Taking Jane in with an ardent video gaze, he is captivated:

JANE
What is it?

ANGELA
It’s that psycho next door. . .

JANE
I bet he’s filming us right now.

Voyeurism and exhibitionism loop, as through the camera lens Ricky seeks out Jane from his bedroom window:

On VIDEO: We’re across from Jane’s window, peering in. Jane tries to shut the drapes, but Angela won’t let her. Irritated, Jane retreats into the room. We ZOOM toward her, even as Angela poses in the window, waving, but we’re clearly not interested in Angela. The ZOOM continues, searching for Jane . . . Finally, we settle on the full-length MIRROR on the open closet door, where we see a REFLECTION of Jane . . .  She’s smiling.

Lester continues to be directed by change: “It’s a great thing to realize you still have the ability to surprise yourself. Makes you wonder what else you can do that you’ve forgotten about . . .”

He meets Ricky’s father, Colonel Frank Fitts, U.S. Marine Corps, a man locked in a perpetual vise grip of impotent rage, and always suspicious (impact character thematic counterpoint) of what goes on in his son’s life. Immoral and/or illegal:

RICKY
. . . G-13 . . . genetically engineered by the U.S. Government. Extremely potent. But a completely mellow high, no paranoia. . . Two grand.

LESTER
. . . Well, now I know how you can afford all this equipment. When I was your age, I worked at McDonald’s all summer just to buy an eight track. . .  it was probably the best time of my life (main character concern-past).

RICKY
My dad thinks I paid for all this with catering jobs. Never underestimate the power of denial (overall story inhibitor-senses).

Lester and Carolyn’s marriage is another relationship on trial:

CAROLYN
This is not a marriage.

LESTER
This hasn’t been a marriage for years. But you were perfectly happy as long as I kept my mouth shut. Well, guess what? I’ve changed (main character direction).

The vicissitudes include Lester quitting his job (after blackmailing his boss for a sweet severance package), hiring on at a fast food restaurant, and indulging in adolescent fantasies (overall story dividend-the past). Incensed, Carolyn relieves her stress by bopping Leonard Kane-The Real Estate King-and obsessively shooting a “Glock 19” automatic revolver at the local firing range.

Ricky confides his fierce obsession to Jane: “I knew there was this entire life behind things, and . . . this incredibly benevolent force, that wanted me to know there was no reason to be afraid. Ever. Video’s a poor excuse. But it helps remember . . . and I need to remember . . .” (impact character concern-memory.

Ricky must recall all instances of beauty to survive as the only child of a desensitized (overall story inhibitor-senses) mother and militaristic father:

COLONEL
You need structure, you need discipline (impact character focus-order).

INSANITY

Ultimately, the fairytale of an American family (overall story goal-conceptualizing) fractures(outcome-failure):

LESTER
Remember those posters that said, “Today is the first day of the rest of your life.”  Well, that’s true of every day except one. The day you die.

A day of cataclysmic decisions.

Colonel Fitts misinterprets (relationship story thematic counterpoint) the relationship between Lester and Ricky as homosexual. An avowed homophobic, he brutally evicts his son from their home. The Colonel is only repressing his own feelings (overall story solution-actuality). Unpredictably (main character thematic issue) he kisses Lester on the mouth. Lester compassionately rebuffs his advances, unaware of the impossible circumstances (overall story catalyst) in which the Colonel now (overall story forewarnings-present) finds himself.

Ricky asks Jane to run away with him:

RICKY
If I had to leave tonight, would you come with me? If I went to New York. To live. Tonight. Would you come with me?

JANE
Yes.

Angela, alienated from Jane and Ricky, is determined to follow through with her seductive promise to Lester. Until:

ANGELA
This is my first time (overall story solution-actuality).

Reality check (main character solution-actuality). Lester decides not to deflower this American beauty (main character resolve-change).

Morality gives way to mortality. The Colonel silently returns and takes a gun to Lester. Carolyn, arriving on the scene, gathers Lester’s empty suits in her arms, understanding (overall story consequence) the husband she so contemptuously dismissed, is really gone (limit-optionlock).

HUMANITY

Lester takes his demise philosophically:

LESTER
. . . it’s hard to stay mad when there’s so much beauty in the world. Sometimes I feel like I’m seeing it all at once (main character mental sex-female), and it’s too much, my heart fills up like a balloon that’s about to burst . . . and then I remember to relax, and stop trying to hold on to it, and then it flows through me like rain and I can’t feel anything but gratitude for every single moment (main character judgement-good) of my stupid little life . . .

A life of artifice and the ordinary redeemed by an appreciation for the extraordinary.

NOTE: Since the time of this article’s publication, it has been determined that the storyform presented above was inaccurate in regard to one key story point: the Main Character’s Problem-Solving Style (now Linear).

Ding Dong. Avon Calling.

by KEM Huntley

Within walking distance, is the North Hollywood Amelia Earhart Regional Library.  Scanning its NoHo calendar, I am lured in by a recent literary event vignette:

“King Tut, the invention of the automobile, a TV game show, and a tiny cactus parasite all profoundly affected the face we show the world.  How did red lipstick impact the women suffrage movement?  With seemingly unrelated trivia, DeBus reveals odd connections and presents some of her vintage makeup collection.”

I am most intrigued to visit the one-story Spanish Colonial Revival style stucco Mission style library that honors our most famous aviatrix.  Its humble beginnings—two bookcases housed in a corner of the City of Lankershim’s post office.

With a stylish air and natural flair for storytelling, San Fernando Historical Society Board Member Maya DeBus presented, “History & Make-up:  ‘How Events Shaped How We Look:  Intriguing, Whimsical, and Little-Known Connections.’”

          Ms. DeBus opened with the acknowledgment that embellished faces are global, attributed to religion, magic, power, and sometimes—witchcraft.  She showed the Norman Rockwell “Girl at Mirror,” to point out how we gaze at our blank slates, dreaming of a transformed state.  (Fun Fact, my second . . . maybe third . . . cousins modeled for at least two of The Saturday Evening Post covers.  One as twins.  Great Uncle Edwin Eberman co-founded The Famous Artists School with this Americana Life’s gent.)

Ms. DeBus subscribes to the notion that “Red Lips Kiss My Blues Away”— a sentiment to which I concur.  “Cosmetic” comes from the Greek word, kosmētik, “the art of dress and ornament.  The art is ancient, and Ms. DeBus fascinated the crowd as she regaled tales of Queens Elizabeth and Victoria, actresses and ladies of the evening, painted ladies, and “Blue Bloods”—society ladies faces paled with products such as Dr. Campbell’s “Arsenic Complexion Wafers,” who drew blue lines on the sides of their faces to indicate veins.

Ms. Debus ordered the art of the artifice both chronologically and by facial features.  Inside this California native’s bag of tricks and historical tidbits (also known as the “ring purse”), included intel on Max Factor, who was originally a wigmaker in Imperial Russia.  After emigrating to first NY then LA, he discovered the need for film stars to wear something other than theatrical make-up, aka “grease paint” under the blaze of hot camera lights.  The make-up spells he created so well oftentimes “disappeared” on set, compelling Max to set up shop in Hollywood.

Further factoids include New York City’s Suffragette’s paraded wearing red lipstick supplied by ardent feminist Elizabeth Arden.  Plus, the cochineal insect, essentially produces carmine that deters predation, and used for red lipstick—oftentimes used for the same purpose. 

Ms. DeBus has not yet published her findings; however, she is looking forward to receiving kTVision’s 4th Grade teacher’s field trip report:  MayaSpeaks@aol.com.  Perhaps I can tease her purple prose into a polished, published piece of true art.  Or, I can just steer her towards Bésame Cosmetics in Burbank.  Founded out of a fascination with art, history, and beauty by artist, cosmetic historian, and designer Gabriela Hernandez; her chic boutique boasts a “. . . vintage makeup brand which honors the style, spirit, and sensibility of female beauty.”  Not to mention, she wrote the book, Classic Beauty:  The History of Makeup.

I wear House of Bésame’s 1941 inspired gilded, lipstick bullet, “Victory Red.”  My glam gram, Bow Bow, once the object of Oscar Hammerstein the II’s affection, would be pleased prettily.

Postscript”  “Collage is not all that she does,” was the first snippet of conversation I overheard in room of perhaps twelve library patrons.  Completely random and in no way in regard to Ms. DeBus; however, an epitaph I may use for a future grave marker.

Opium

by Julio Peralta-Paulino

Day was well past coffee and breakfast — even if at Parthenon the first meal of the day wasn’t much more than some dusty Danish — when Heisenberg’s green line rang.

“Oh, yes the teen vampire project.  I like this draft.  What are we calling it?”

He asked without any expectation of a response.

“The sophomore version.  Yes yes the problem as I see it is that it should either be a vampire film or a werewolf movie, but this mixture it’s simply too either or and I don’t want that and I don’t think that what’s her name wants that.”

There was a pause as if to give the novelist some credit for coming up with the series of words that had made a book and was now being transcribed into a screenplay by a scribbler that knew, in the opinion of Heisenberg and for that matter Parthenon, what it truly meant to write.

That is to say, being oblivious to nearly everything but the all important plot and the not so important sub-plot.

“I’d love to get that Soy Popula on this, but that brat thinks she’s Hollywood royalty.  Next thing you know, we’ll be stuck making the next Norman space sci-fi adventure vehicle set in Paris.  I got enough worries . . . Let me make some calls and see what the schedules are like for Winter season.  I’ll get back to you, in the meanwhile, cut out the dogs, you know the wolves, and make it something more sexy — uhm, maybe he turns into bird — a pretty bird — half vulture and half falcon.  Now, get right on that before I sign the director.”

Heidelberg hadn’t seen it all, but he’d seen enough.  He especially held witness to the continual lack of major worldwide box office at Parthenon.  It was fair to say he was an agitated man in need of something spectacular for his prodco.  Parthenon was one of the old time players.  Old as far as anything could possibly be old in an ever-young city like Los Angeles.  It was rather simply mostly farmland when cinema was taking its early steps.  A dream much like Las Vegas, but a drama that would quickly evolve into one of the world’s most alluring attractions.  When America went to war, Parthenon went to war—with R rated films.  Even so, none of their movies were ever among the top-grossing of all time, they didn’t have the type of weekend openings one might be inclined to associate with a name such as Parthenon Studios.

Every so often H, as Heidelberg was nicknamed by those near enough his acquaintenances not to be threatened with being fired or worse, would say to himself, “Well, Gigantic was massive and they had to split the loot with Teamworks, and after I’ve been here we had Reformers but also in partnership with Twenty Cent Locks; it’s probably one of those movie things.”  Sometimes, when H practiced infidelity and he did so every Thursday and every long weekend available to himself and his revolving convoy of escorts, he’d whisper afterwards:  “The thing I worry about is the Artisan Curse.”  Of course, he wouldn’t explain what that was to his momentary mistress except to add:  “They had a good thing with the Rare Witch Project, but they went for the sequel and it killed them.”  If the fun was outside the ordinary, H would include a concluding thought to his confessional whisper:  “It’s the age of the sequel, but some movies simply cannot be made.”

Months passed, H was never pleased with the photo-play in progress, much as loved the potential.  “It needs something.   It has romance, sure.  I don’t know, maybe a bimbo mobile?”  From his experience, it was clear, when a movie starts to feel like work then it might not be worth producing.  It might just start to feel like a workload to the goer that has to carry it for two hours in a dark room.

The afternoon came early.  One conference call and suddenly his secretary handed him the green line and the words went around the room, “Let the lawyers find a new team for this screenplay.  I already got one with the same title out, it’s been knocking at my distraction for months, and we really need to concentrate on that love story with the three-legged cat.”

When the first Vampire film did well, there was some uneasiness surrounding Parthenon and H.  Still, it was — as many people tend to say — “one of those things.”  They got lucky or they deserved something for having the balls to put Christmas Nicci as a piglet in a stinker. A tolerable folly.  Once in a while, to his wife, in the late evenings, he’d say, “Maybe I should have had some more patience with the werewolf side of the thing.”

Powerful men are not usually prone to remorse or regret.  Tears are rare, although fears might be fruitful.  H was being driven to one of the hideaways just outside L.A. in the Autumn when the sequel to the project he had sent back into negotiations appeared.

The long lines made him think, “Hmmm kids, looks like another winner, this business is insane.  No telling what might strike up the ticket band.”  He took a Tambien, which was a popular medication in those days even if the side effects included self-extermination.  He went to bed, shaking from the text-message realization that it had made seventy million in a few hours showing.  The words echoed like cold leftovers in the gut of his thoughts, “This isn’t even the big weekend.”

That first not even the big weekend the movie grossed 153 milliion domestic.  It was bigger than many of the big movies and cost a fraction of what they had been budgeted.  It was big news.  Excellent news, in fact, for the industry.  It simply wasn’t news that Parthenon, and especially H could relish.

After only two weeks the world-wide total was estimated at four hundred and seventy million dollars.  All of it within an international recession, possible flu-epidemic, and the talk of global warming looming over the earthly population.

One might have expected a place like Parthenon to demote or even deliver Heidelberg his walking papers.  “Didn’t the guy from the mailroom look a lot like H?  If you can’t get me on screen anymore then I don’t have half an hour to make your pasta al dente.”

Of course, often something as dramatic as the sequel’s triumph turns heads so entirely that nothing is said and things go on as they had before the rights were let go to some other contender.

Day was well past teas and biscuits—even if at Parthenon the first meal of the day wasn’t much more than some hasty fruit—when Heisenberg’s private line rang.

“Oh yes.  That reminds me, I need something stronger than my current prescription.  Would Morphine be too difficult?” He asked, entirely expecting the Rx Fedexed before the pome disappeared from its decomposing position alongside the oversized Rolodex.

Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?

by KEM Huntley

“Want to see it again little girl? It shouldn’t frighten you.” The opening scene of a crying Jack in the Box toy forebodes the strangeness yet to come.

Director Robert Aldrich and writer Lukas Heller’s What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? (based on a novel by Henry Farrell), is classic horror saved from camp by its fine performances. The story of sibling rivalry gone mad necessitates the highly wrought performances from its lead actresses, Bette Davis and Joan Crawford. The sparse supporting cast play their individual parts with enough verve to make them memorable, yet with the restraint required to allow two of Hollywood’s Grande Dames fued.

In 1917, Baby Jane Hudson (main character) is a wildly popular child song and dance act on the vaudeville circuit. Tyrannical behind the scenes, her heart belongs to daddy and her earnings support the show business family. “I want an ice cream. . . . I want it! I make the money so I can have what I want.”

Mother understands (overall story consequence) Jane’s stardom will be short lived, and the real talent lies in big sister Blanche (impact character).

MOTHER

You’re the lucky one Blanche, really you are. Someday it’s going to be you that’s getting all the attention (impact character benchmark-future). And when that happens, I want you to try to be kinder to Jane and your father than they are to you now. . . . I hope you’ll try and remember that (overall story dividend-memory).

Bitterly, Blanche replies: “I won’t forget. You bet I won’t forget!”

Cut to 1935. Baby Jane is a B movie actress.  Blanche, “the biggest thing in movies today.” Blanche has the clout to insist (impact character unique ability-interdiction) Jane receive film work—much to the chagrin of the industry:

PROJECTIONIST 1

When the old man hired the Hudson sisters, how come he had to hire the back end of the act too? Boy, what a no-talent broad that Baby Jane is.

PROJECTIONIST 2

Why can’t she stay sober?

Later, a studio head remarks: “She [Blanche] ought to have sense (relationship story thematic issue) enough to know that she can’t make a star out of Baby Jane again.”

Up to this point, enough information is given to provide backstory for the sisters’ twisted relationship. The next scene is an automobile pulling up to the Hudson residence—one sister opens the gate, the other attempts to run her down (story driver-action). A shriek and a sob and the credits open the film to present day.

Blanche is bound physically to a wheelchair (impact character domain-universe); Jane bound emotionally to her sister by guilt (relationship story domain-physics). They live as recluses with intermittent household help. Nosy Parker neighbor comments: “How come we never see her [Blanche] around? We’ve been living next door (overall thematic issue-situation) for six months now, and the only one I ever see is that fat sister slouching around. Don’t they ever have company? . . . Julie says that sister is kind of peculiar (main character thematic issue-suspicion). . . she’s supposed to be (overall problem-perception) responsible for the accident that crippled her sister Blanche.”

The local television station is broadcasting (impact character signpost 1-present) Blanche’s classic films (impact character concern-past), an event that pleases her, yet raises Jane’s ire (relationship story symptom-self-aware; overall story catalyst-circumstances). A vitriolic alcoholic (overall story symptom-chaos), Jane’s increasing jealousy (main character benchmark-subconscious) and strange behavior (overall story domain-psychology) is cause for Elvira, the Hudson’s’ housekeeper, to prod Blanche to sell the house and conceptualize (overall story goal) a way to put Jane “where they can look after her properly.”

BLANCHE

We’ll probably have to sell the house.

JANE

When did our business manager tell you all this?

BLANCHE

Early last week, I think.

JANE

. . . Oh you’re a liar. You’re just a liar! You always were (impact character solution-actuality). . . . Don’t you think I know everything that goes on in this house (relationship story response-aware)? . . . Blanche, you aren’t ever going to sell this house (relationship story inhibitor-destiny).

Jane, furious, disconnects Blanche’s bedroom telephone (relationship story thematic issue-senses) and serves up a dead pet bird for lunch.

Determined (main character domain-mind) to make a comeback (main character critical flaw-sense of self), Jane places an ad in the personals to hire a musical accompanist. She equivocates to Elvira to keep her out of the way—and away from interfering with Blanche:

JANE

You can have the whole day off.

ELVIRA

Well thanks, but does . . . Miss Blanche know about my taking the day off?

JANE

Oh sure, she knows (overall story inhibitor-falsehood).

Jane receives her gentleman caller garishly made up and dressed in ghastly Baby Jane apparel. Edwin, a musician and mama’s boy, is a bit of a con artist (overall story signpost 3-being). Financial circumstances (overall story catalyst) have compelled him to answer Jane’s ad. He overlooks Jane’s bizarre behavior-intent on following his own agenda (overall story concern-psychology).

JANE

I’m Baby Jane Hudson.

EDWIN

(Taken aback. He obviously has no clue who she is. He makes a quick recovery.)

Oh. Do you mean you’re really the Baby Jane Hudson?

JANE

Yes I am. And I’m going to revive my act exactly as I used to do it. Of course some of the arrangements will have to be brought up to date. Music changes (main character problem) so much, doesn’t it? . . . There are a lot of people who remember me (main character concern-memory). Lots of them.

While Jane is out with Edwin, Blanche crawls downstairs to telephone the doctor. Jane catches her in the act, overhearing Blanche inform Dr. Shelby her sister is “emotionally disturbed.” Jane calls him back, impersonating Blanche (main character approach-be-er), to put the doctor’s mind at ease (overall outcome-failure).

The women’s relationship deteriorates further when Jane bashes Elvira over the head. Jane trusses Blanche up and gags her mouth (relationship story thematic issue-senses). Blanche’s last link to humanity is Edwin. Now a frequent visitor, his mother’s recounting of the Hudson sisters’ scandal does not deter him from playing along with Baby Jane. Once he (overall solution) sees Blanche, dying from dehydration and starvation, he runs out (overall symptom-chaos), a weak, drunk, and frightened man.

(Or was it the lifelike, genuine Baby Jane doll that scared him off?)

Jane believes “he’s gone to tell” (main character thematic counterpoint-evidence) and bundles Blanche off into the car—heading for the beach (relationship story signpost 4-doing). Lying on the sand, near death, Blanche confesses to Jane (impact character resolve-change):

BLANCHE

Jane, I made you waste your whole life thinking you’d crippled me (relationship story problem-perception). . . . You didn’t do it Jane. I did it myself. Don’t you understand (relationship story concern)? I crippled myself. You weren’t driving that night. . . . You were too drunk. . . . You’d been so cruel to me . . . I wanted to run you down—crush you. But you saw the car coming. I hit the gates. I snapped my spine.

JANE

You mean, all this time we could have been friends? (relationship story solution-actuality)

The police then catch up to insane Baby Jane, dancing on the sand, strawberry ice cream in hand (main character resolve-steadfast; main character judgment-good).